Gotham Coffee Roasters logo

Gotham Coffee Roasters

Brooklyn, NY

Gotham Coffee Roasters is a New York City coffee shop and roaster, established in 2013 by Chris Calkins, a coffee industry veteran with deep roots in the specialty coffee movement. The company operates from its Brooklyn roastery at 175 Van Dyke Street and runs a flagship café in Manhattan's Flatiron district at 23 W 19th Street. Founded by Chris Calkins, who was mentored by legendary coffee pioneer Alfred Peet (founder of Peet's Coffee and the man who originally roasted coffee for Starbucks), Gotham represents a unique lineage in specialty coffee. Calkins brings decades of experience, having worked with the original Starbucks founders at their Pike Place Market flagship store, co-founded Spinelli Coffee in San Francisco, and previously co-founded Prodigy Coffee in Greenwich Village. Gotham specializes in two distinct offerings: carefully selected single-origin coffees from small lots or single farms that change frequently, and two signature year-round blends - the Brooklyn and Red Hook blends, developed over six years. The company prides itself on its blended coffee model, only purchasing coffees that can stand alone and combining them to create something greater than the sum of their parts. The company's sourcing philosophy emphasizes economic sustainability for coffee producers, favoring partnerships with small companies that buy cherry or parchment coffee and handle their own import/export operations. This streamlined approach provides greater transparency into buying practices and farm-level prices, allowing partners to pay higher premiums through fixed pricing systems. Beyond retail operations, Gotham has extensive wholesale and consultation experience, having helped build out over a dozen cafés in the New York area and developed numerous coffee programs. The company offers comprehensive wholesale services, equipment sales, and coffee subscriptions featuring both year-round blends and rotating single-origin selections. Gotham Coffee Roasters embodies authenticity, lineage, excellence, and community, viewing coffee as part of a larger global connection from growers to consumers. As Calkins notes, "We're part of something bigger than the beans. We're part of a long history."

Founded

2013

Report a correction · Sources and methodology

Available Coffees

Brooklyn Blend

Brooklyn Blend

Gotham Coffee Roasters • Brooklyn, NY

$22.00 · $1.83/oz

BlendWashed

Varieties

BourbonTypica

Chocolate • Raspberry • Sweet

Brooklyn Blend is Gotham Coffee Roasters' signature year-round coffee, designed as a balanced crowd-pleaser that appeals to any coffee drinker. This classic American house blend is crafted with an emphasis on balance, sweetness, and simplicity, featuring a rotating selection of high-quality components from Mexico and Colombia. The blend includes coffees...

Colombia - El Nogal

Colombia - El Nogal

Gotham Coffee Roasters • Brooklyn, NY

$30.00 · $2.50/oz

Single OriginColombiaWashed

Varieties

Pink Bourbon

Fig • Mandarin Orange • Red Currant

Colombia El Nogal is a washed Pink Bourbon from Finca El Nogal in Santa María, Huila, where young producer Andrés Felipe Osorio Trujillo farms with his family. Roasted by Gotham Coffee Roasters, with fig, mandarin orange, and red currant.

Decaf - Mexico Chiapas

Decaf - Mexico Chiapas

Gotham Coffee Roasters • Brooklyn, NY

$24.00 · $2.00/oz

Single OriginMexicoMountain Water Process
Decaf

Brown Sugar • Dark Chocolate • Figs

Decaf Mexico Chiapas is a single-origin mountain-water decaf with brown sugar, dark chocolate, and figs. It works as espresso or filter, a chocolate-leaning cup for when you want the same coffee without the caffeine.

Diner Coffee (Darker Roast)

Diner Coffee (Darker Roast)

Gotham Coffee Roasters • Brooklyn, NY

$24.00 · $2.00/oz

Single OriginGuatemalaWashed

Dark Chocolate • Fig • Cinnamon

Diner Coffee is Gotham's darker year-round roast, an homage to bottomless diner cups with dark chocolate, fig, and cinnamon. They roast this single-origin lot darker than their blends so sweetness and body hold up in a rich drip cup.

Ethiopia - Qabballe Natural

Ethiopia - Qabballe Natural

Gotham Coffee Roasters • Brooklyn, NY

$28.00 · $2.33/oz

Single OriginEthiopiaNatural

Varieties

7411074112

Lemongrass • Floral • Sweet

Ethiopia Qabballe Natural comes from Sookoo Coffee's Raro Nansebo washing station in Guji, grown on cold, high-elevation farms. Roasted by Gotham Coffee Roasters, this natural is lemongrass-bright, floral, and sweet.

Nicaragua - Finca un Regalo de Dios

Nicaragua - Finca un Regalo de Dios

Gotham Coffee Roasters • Brooklyn, NY

$24.00 · $2.00/oz

Single OriginNicaraguaNatural

Varieties

Yellow Catuai

Very Fruity • Crisp Acidity • Balanced Sweetness

Nicaragua Finca un Regalo de Dios is a natural Yellow Catuai from Luis Alberto in Nueva Segovia. Cherries dry 25-30 days. The cup is very fruity, with crisp acidity and balanced sweetness from this Cup of Excellence-winning farm.

Red Hook Espresso

Red Hook Espresso

Gotham Coffee Roasters • Brooklyn, NY

$22.00 · $1.83/oz

BlendWashed

Varieties

BourbonTypica

Cocoa • Dates • Citrus

Red Hook Espresso is Gotham's year-round house espresso, named for the Brooklyn neighborhood where they roast. This washed Brazil and Colombia blend brings cocoa, dates, and citrus, with body for milk drinks and brightness to drink on its own.

Rough Rider Roast

Rough Rider Roast

Gotham Coffee Roasters • Brooklyn, NY

$27.00 · $2.25/oz

Single OriginColombiaWashed

Varieties

BourbonTypica

Bittersweet Chocolate • Spiced Rum • Dried Cherry

Rough Rider Roast is a darker seasonal single origin from Huila, Colombia, honoring Theodore Roosevelt's New York coffee habit. The washed Bourbon and Typica cup is heavy and rich, with bittersweet chocolate, spiced rum, and dried cherry.